The choke collar for dogs is a training and learning tool used by some dog teachers and some owners to teach the animal to walk with its owner’s leash on without pulling. This approach, which operates on the principle of pain and fear, has been widely criticized by followers of positive educational approaches aimed at developing good manners to encourage the doggie to repeat and integrate it. It should also be noted that the choke collar, which therefore applies the principle of education through punishment, is often used in the wrong way. If it has a specific use in some targeted context, many masters use it poorly to the point of hurting their little partner. If they get quick results, let’s not hide the fact that the choke collar can have physical and psychological doggie consequences if misused.
How does a dog collar work? What is its use? What are the effects and risks? We suggest that you examine the whole question on this topic to allow you to make an informed choice.
The choke collar for dogs: how does it work?
There are several types of choke collars for dogs:
The steel choke collar : this basic model is intended to make it easier for the dog to pull on its leash while walking. In this case, his master would only have to pull on the leash so that the collar would tighten around the dog’s neck, resulting in a slight feeling of numbness that would bother him to the point that he would be forced to stay in place.
The leather choke collar : this type of choke collar works on the same principle as the steel choke collar, but the material is different. The more expensive the leather, the more expensive and more aesthetic these models are.
The semi-choker collar : this type of collar is intended to limit the feeling of irritation compared to the previous ones, but it produces almost the same effect all the same. However, the swallowing was of little intensity.
The spiked choke collar or the semi-spiked choke collar : this type of model has spikes that tighten around the dog’s neck when he pulls his leash. Although reported disease -free, this measure is debatable because the spikes press down on the animal’s neck.
The principle of operation of the choke collar for dogs
The choke collar for dogs is used by some owners and teachers to teach the dog to stop pulling on his leash while walking. To do this, this type of collar has a pressure similar to a light strangulation of the animal’s neck when the doggie pulls on the leash.
So the choke collar is a conditioning thing that uses negative association to prevent the animal from giving birth to a trait, in this case, here, the fact of pulling his leash. By triggering a negative response for the doggie, the collar should make it clear to him that he needs to walk on foot without pulling. The dog therefore associates the difficulty with the pulling motion and, in order not to suffer the negative effect of the barking, he avoids changing the behavior being targeted.
When the animal can no longer stay at its master’s feet and it catches him during the walk, or when it reaches the end of the leash and tries to go forward, the master will give a sharp haul. on the string, called “bell ring”. This action has the effect of triggering a slight choke effect.
A questionable process
Nowadays, learning through kindness and positive reinforcement is the method recommended by most canine educators. This is clearly self-evident and it is based on the principle of dog cooperation through encouragement and praise. The doggie was happy to satisfy his master and was fully involved in his learning.
However, the choke collar is not based on the same principle. It is based on the association of discomfort – even pain – with a specific behavior to encourage the dog not to breed it so as not to suffer. The animal ends up following out of fear, and not of understanding the right move.
Because of this, Dog trainers advise against using a choke collar in the context of initial education. It is considered very brutal for the young pooch to learn the first rules of dog life. On the other hand, experts believe, for some, that it may be suitable for rehabilitation for a dog that is difficult to handle.
It is actually considered more effective and harmonious for the animal to value its good behavior in order to strengthen it rather than punish bad deeds. The dog understands very well that in order to get what he wants (the reward), he has to act in a certain way. So he was happy to repeat the right move to be rewarded and congratulated by his master, until this move was fully integrated and became natural. Cooperation is always more effective than fear, especially since banning a behavior does not lead to learning right!
In fact, good and positive approaches take a lot of time and patience. In contrast, the discomfort of barking can quickly cause the dog to stop pulling on his leash. On the other hand, it should be noted that dog education is not based on speed, but efficiency. Like a small child, the dog needs time and repetition to put together a new order. Going too fast can always ruin the master’s efforts, so it’s important to break everything down into stages that need to be linked progressively and evenly. The brutality of the choke collar saves time, but the animal loses the trust of its master who would have reassured and insured it. He respected instructions out of restraint and fear above all else.
Like many training tools, the choke collar for dogs should be used by owners who want to do it with full knowledge of the rules of its use so as not to put the doggie at risk. Don’t hesitate to seek advice from your veterinarian or a dog behaviorist to find out if this tool is made for your little companion.
The choke collar for dogs: what are its dangers?
If it is misused – which unfortunately is often the case – the choke collar for dogs can have harmful consequences for the doggie.
The risks of physical sequelae
Using a choke collar is not without risk for the dog. Here are the physical consequences it can have if used incorrectly:
- It can cause damage to the neck, skin, trachea, larynx and vertebrae of the dog. An action taken at the wrong time can harm the animal.
- The risk of malfunction is possible, as it happens with the electric collar. If the collar is not used or permanently worn by the dog, it can cause serious consequences for the animal. Also keep in mind that it must be placed in a specific way, otherwise it can be pinched in a position to be bent.
- If the choke collar is left permanently around the dog’s neck, the animal may be caught in a pull barrier and block the tool, risking injury.
The risks of psychological sequelae
Physical sequelae are not the only ones that need to be considered. The animal may be subject to psychological sequelae if this product is used in the wrong way:
- The pain caused by strangulation can create stress in the dog, even traumatic. This phenomenon is likely to promote the occurrence of a more frightening behavior in the animal, or more aggressive.
- The animal may lose trust in its master. This is to protect him and ensure his comfort. Associating it with pain can upset the dog who may be afraid of his master.
- Doggies can be associated with pain in the elements around them. If he sees another dog, if he meets people or if he is in a certain environment when he receives the bell, the animal may associate with them in pain and develop negative behavior, even fear. or aggressive towards them.
- If the doorbell is not given at the right time to the owner or if he does not master the use and/or power of the collar, the message can be confusing for the dog, who no longer knows what to think. .